New York - Criteria: C (architecture/engineering)
| Old City Road Stone Arch Bridge |
| Old Colony Club |
| Old Croton Dam, Site of |
| Old Episcopal Manse |
| Old First Church |
| Old First Reformed Church |
| Old Fort House |
| Old Grolier Club |
| Old Homer Village Historic District |
| Old House, The |
| Old Lutheran Parsonage |
| Old Madison County Courthouse |
| Old Merchant's House |
| Old Nassau County Courthouse |
| Old New York Evening Post Building |
| Old Parsonage |
| Old Post Office |
| Old Post Office |
| Old Quaker Meetinghouse |
| Old School Baptist Church of Halcottsville |
| Old Sloatsburg Cemetery |
| Old Southeast Church |
| Old Southeast Town Hall |
| Old State Road Bridge |
| Old Stone Barracks |
| Old Stone Fort |
| Old Stone Warehouse |
| Old St. Patrick's Cathedral Complex |
| Old St. Peter's Church |
| Old Town Cemetery and Palatine Church Site |
| Old Town Green Historic District |
| Old Town Hall Historic District |
| Old Town of Flushing Burial Ground |
| Old Trees |
| Old Troy Hospital |
| Old Warren County Courthouse Complex |
| Old Westbury Gardens |
| Olean Armory |
| Olean Public Library |
| Olean School #10 |
| Olive and Hurley Old School Baptist Church |
| Oliver Avenue Bridge |
| Oliver, Thomas, House |
| Olivet Chapel |
| Olmstead Street Historic District |
| Onderdonk, Horatio Gates, House |
| Onderdonk House |
| Oneida Armory |
| Oneida Lake Congregational Church |
| Oneonta Armory |
| Oneonta Downtown Historic District |
| Oneonta Theatre |
| Onesquethaw Valley Historic District |
| Onondaga County Savings Bank Building |
| Onondaga County War Memorial |
| Onondaga Highlands-Swaneola Heights Historic District |
| Onondaga Park |
| Ontario and Livingston Mutual Insurance Office |
| Ontario and Western Railroad Passenger Station |
| Onteora Park Historic District |
| Oppenheim and St. Johnsville Union Society Church |
| Opus 40 |
| Oran Community Church |
| Oran District No. 22 Schoolhouse |
| Orange Mill Historic District |
| Orchard Shoal Light Station, Old |
| Ordway, Jones, House |
| Orient Historic District |
| Orient Point Light Station |
| Orleans County Courthouse Historic District |
| Ormonde |
| Ormsby-Laughlin Textile Companies Mill |
| Osborn-Bouton-Mead House |
| Osborne Apartments |
| Osborne House |
| Osburn, Mrs., House |
| Osceola Town Hall |
| Osgood, J.C., Firehouse |
| Oswegatchie Pumping Station |
| Oswego and Syracuse Railroad Freight House |
| Oswego Armory |
| Oswego City Hall |
| Oswego City Library |
| Oswego County Courthouse |
| Oswego Meeting House and Friends' Cemetery |
| Oswego-Oneida Streets Historic District |
| Oswego Theater |
| Oswego West Pierhead Lighthouse |
| Oswego Yacht Club |
| Otis, Job and Deborah, House |
| Otsdawa Baptist Church |
| Otsego County Courthouse |
| Ottendorfer Public Library and Stuyvesant Polyclinic Hospital |
| Otter Lake Community Church |
| Ouaquaga Lenticular Truss Bridge |
| Oulagisket |
| Our Lady of Victory Roman Catholic Church |
| Our Mother of Sorrows Roman Catholic Church Complex |
| Overackers Corners Schoolhouse |
| Overlook |
Data from United States Park Service and Wikidata
